Great Broken Railway

(1) The double-track Uckfield–Lewes main line.

(2) GBR – The South’s Great Broken Railway.

(3) Ruined for the sake of 7 missing miles.

(4) “Sussex railways are the most congested in the UK.” – Network Rail

(5) “We would like to have more capacity for trains from the South Coast into London.” – Southern. “The Brighton main line is one of a number of routes on which the provision of further capacity is difficult.” – The Department for Transport.


Former Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, never uttered a truer comment when saying of Sussex “– a part of the country so often ignored, or left behind under previous Governments”.

But given recent pronouncements on regional transport investment, it appears current Chancellor Rachel Reeves is determined to keep it that way.

Last year we had great hopes for Sir Keir Starmer because he told us he grew up in Hurst Green on the Uckfield Line. Having made so much of his humble origins during canvassing the southern counties pre-election, his interest in this persistently neglected corner of the realm in London’s shadow now seems non-existent after all. With well over £15billion of investment recently announced for transport elsewhere – no concern is shown towards Sussex with its overloaded and still-broken rail network – just left to struggle on.

Network Rail and the train operators know full-well how critically-overloaded the one main line between Brighton and London remains – they’ve said so themselves – countless times.... Yet still nothing happens, despite its plight having been raised in Parliament and the media across many decades. The so-called Department for Transport continues to repeatedly dismiss the one-and-only widely-acknowledged solution which even those in the House of Lords as well as Westminster have backed as the only practicable and truly effective solution – reinvigorate the adjacent Wealden Main Line.

Of one thing we can be absolutely certain is that the go-ahead for London Gatwick’s second runway this autumn will add an even more unbearable strain on the Brighton line. This will mean yet more intolerable jam-packed trains, as well as extra trains jostling for what is termed ‘route capacity’ – there simply is no more.

Instead, we unworthy, miserable and undeserving Southerners are abandoned; left to not only continue campaigning to reinstate a paltry few miles of railway line, but now battle the civil servants in the DfT as well as our Lib Dem and Green political adversaries from turning the Brighton Line’s previous alternative route (up until 1969) into a ‘Greenway’ bike path. Dressed up as ‘Active Travel’ – which is asinine terminology for having to walk, cycle, ‘wheel’ (skateboard or wheelchair) rather than have a swift train journey – we are left wondering why our Northern counterparts aren’t pursuing, let alone being offered, this same ‘alternative’.

Network Rail needs to seriously get its act together. Having said on numerous occasions that the Uckfield–Lewes trackbed should continue to be rigorously protected, it should now be demanding Statutory Authority for this to be ratified by the Secretary of State for Transport, who similarly needs to get a grip. It has disgracefully been left to the Wealden Line Campaign (which next month enters its fortieth year!) to relentlessly look after the Uckfield Line’s interests and protect it from all number of hostile acts of wilful destruction, harmful road projects and other planning schemes.

Mindful of the DfT’s antipathy towards this former main line, last summer we wrote to Network Rail’s CEO Andrew Haines (since retired and duly knighted) as well as its then chairman Lord Peter Hendy (now ensconced as Labour’s Transport Minister). We duly received a response from NR’s Southern Region Public Affairs Manager, who affirmed: ‘We appreciate the importance of the railway, both past and present in local communities – this includes the former line between Lewes and Uckfield. It is our understanding that the Uckfield to Lewes track bed is protected as part of Wealden District Council’s Local Plan’.

Unfortunately – and what needs to start alarm bells ringing is –that is no longer the case.

East Sussex County Council, which wasfirst and foremost determinedly responsible for destroying this main line in the 1960s, surreptitiously altered its protection for ‘low speed, single track operation only’ some years ago.

To our dismay, Network Rail’s assurance about it appreciating the importance of this railway then fell apart after going on to say: ‘In terms of the specifics, old single-track alignments often create challenges and require a large level of reinstatement work to bring them up to modern standards and specifications. These processes also include the provision of passing loops or sections of double track to assist with the day-to-day operations and management of single-track railways. Our Strategic Planning Team here at Network Rail focuses on how the railway in Kent and Sussex can contribute to both national and regional economic growth.’

Upon reading this, our confidence in their Strategic Planning Team nose-dived as Uckfield–Lewes was a double-track main line, operating 50 trains per day until it was quite wilfully destroyed by East Sussex County Council, complicit British Rail management and the equally malignant Ministry of Transport.

Accordingly, last autumn we approached Lord Bassam of Brighton who has been a loyal and stalwart supporter of the Sussex scheme for many years, having facilitated meetings with former rail ministers and other rail-focused Parliamentarians. Steve told Lord Hendy that it’s ‘a quick win in terms of connectivity in the South East, just 7 miles of track restoration’ while forwarding our plea for a Safeguarding Direction. Many Wealden Line Campaign members will recall how the equally heroic Lord Tony Berkeley intervened in 2013 in scuttling East Sussex County Council’s determination to build its ‘Uckfield Gyratory’ – their town centre road scheme on the former station site and severing the track bed. Lord Berkeley successfully had the land transferred to Network Rail ownership for commuter car parking with the track bed fenced-off for its protection.

Unfortunately, minister Peter Hendy’s only response was to simply sign-off the customary anodyne civil service departmental waffle, including the particularly patronising sentence: ‘Please be assured that we are committed to improving rail connectivity in the South East and recognise the social and economic benefits this brings to communities.’

This is an insult to not only our intelligence, but to everyone living in these constantly overlooked southern counties.