The News

  BML2Logo

bringing important railway connections together

 

web148900

1: The pledge given to Sussex by British Railways in May 1957.

2: Purely by chance, Kent got in first; otherwise, Beeching would have trounced it.

3: Newspaper headline in April 1963: The wilful destruction of Sussex’s rail network begins.

4: Gordon Pettitt’s legacy - cross-county railway annihilation at Tunbridge Wells West.


Hailed as ‘one of British Rail’s most-visionary senior managers’, tributes to the late Gordon Pettitt OBE came pouring in following his death in March last year and after a lifetime’s career on the railways. Up until now, we have never had reason to comment upon his record, whilst during this 40 year-long campaign we have never met, corresponded, or had any dealings with him - unlike Chris Green, former Director of Network SouthEast, for whom we will always have the greatest admiration. It was therefore profoundly disturbing to read in July’s Railway Magazine an excerpt from Pettitt’s personal diaries where he reveals, almost to the point of boasting, that he was ‘personally involved’ with the closure of Tunbridge Wells West.

This particularly crucial railway linked Kent and Tunbridge Wells with Surrey and East Sussex (via Ashurst and Eridge respectively). To begin with, Pettitt condemns himself by paying a glowing tribute to Lord Beeching’s ‘Reshaping of British Railways’ report, saying that it was ‘- very positive and that remained my view ever after’. In fact, it was nothing of the kind. Comprising an extremely crude methodology, no allowance was made for through traffic over strategic lines, particularly routes with proven fast-developing custom. Even worse, Tunbridge Wells West never formed part of BR’s network initially touted for closure - as official records reveal. Disastrously, we in the South East are still paying the price for Beeching’s ham-fisted accountancy - as BR’s more erudite managers such as George Weeden gravely warned would be the case.

Here in this continually overlooked region, it was a pure fluke that Kent escaped completely unscathed during Beeching’s era (1961-65). This was down to the 1959 ‘Kent Coast Electrification Scheme’ being completed by June 1961 with fast, frequent services proving immensely successful. The ‘Oxted Lines Electrification Scheme’ had already been agreed and scheduled to immediately follow Kent, with completion by 1964. BR declared: “Our target date for introducing electric trains between London and East Grinstead is 1964 together with services to Brighton via Oxted, Ashurst, Uckfield and Lewes”. Citing a 186% increase in ticket sales even with outdated steam traction, the future was so bright, whilst revenue figures sharply increased at Uckfield line stations.

Even Beeching’s Report showed most Sussex stations were generating considerably more income than many in neighbouring Kent. The only reason Kent got off so lightly was entirely down to politics, coupled with its electrification being given precedence over Sussex. Had these roles been reversed, then the South East rail network would look very different today! Our overloaded Brighton Line would now be reaping many benefits with two relief/secondary main lines; the principal Uckfield Line proving invaluable, whilst the Steyning Line (Shoreham - Horsham) would be both useful and doing very nicely. Tunbridge Wells would have electric services to London via Oxted and Croydon, taking pressure off today’s well-overloaded Tonbridge/Sevenoaks route. Also, electric services from Eastbourne to London via Hailsham - Heathfield - Oxted would serve this expanding area, rather than clogging-up the Brighton Line.

So, in this ‘reverse scenario’ how would Kent have fared? Only the bold lines shown on the BR diagram above would have survived. The North Kent Line via Margate would terminate at Ramsgate, whilst Canterbury would be sufficiently served by the London - Dover line through Faversham, thus dispensing with the Canterbury West line. Sheerness could be pruned and Maidstone East would become a terminus, since there was nothing worth serving towards Ashford. As for Maidstone West - Paddock Wood, records reveal its usage was a third of passenger traffic between Tunbridge Wells West and Lewes; therefore, such services would have been withdrawn.

Instead, turning East Sussex into ‘a railway desert’ was overwhelmingly down to political pressure of the worst kind, aided by unscrupulous British Rail managers with nothing to lose personally. And despite BR consenting to so stupidly cutting-off the busy Uckfield line’s profitable South Coast connections solely for a half-baked road scheme in 1969, electrification was back on the agenda in 1973. This recommended electrifying all the Oxted lines - to East Grinstead/Uckfield and Tunbridge Wells West. In conjunction, a new fleet of class 423 VEP electric trains would operate these services. Significantly, BR scheduled Tunbridge Wells West to be electrified before the borough’s smaller and cramped station on the Hastings line. In conjunction, a rueful BR was considering the possible reinstatement of Uckfield - Lewes following calamitous incidents on the Brighton Line, quite aside from increasing congestion and capacity problems.

But far from pursuing this sensible way forward, both Labour and Conservative politicians, alongside their subservient managers in nationalised British Rail, piled on the pressure to cut costs and ‘make the railways pay’. Slashing grants and forcing BR to sell-off land assets became accelerated Government policy, particularly after Mrs Thatcher walked into Downing Street. Pursuing yet more line closures after the detrimental consequences lingering from the 1960s ‘Beeching era’ seemed unlikely, especially as the clamour to reopen some was growing all the time. Then the bombshell came in 1982 when closure of the strategic link joining Sussex with Kent through Tunbridge Wells was announced.

This was undeniably as catastrophic and damaging to the region as the amputation south of Uckfield under Labour. Until now, all available records we’ve scrutinised have uncovered political pressure to realise BR’s ‘non-operational assets’, notably highly-valuable land to offset the Government’s PSO (Public Sector Obligation) Grant. Characteristically, closure of ‘the Eridge Line’ was cynically timed to coincide with announcing the Tonbridge - Hastings Line electrification. Those valiantly fighting to retain the route in the network diligently challenged BR, even going to the High Court requesting access to its ‘case’ for closure and, more importantly, scrutinising its alleged ‘savings’ in its removal. The judge refused them.

Forty years on, it’s therefore profoundly disturbing to read in Pettitt’s diary that he was instrumental in the closure of Tunbridge Wells to Eridge. He says the line “- was closed with the electrification of the Tunbridge [sic] to Hastings line, which used all the capacity of Tunbridge Wells’ main station. In this case, I spent a whole morning showing the minister of transport around the area before permission for the closure was agreed”. In other words, he virtually told the minister that the line was going to be useless even if it stayed open - so what possible reason would the minister now have to refuse consent for closure? What a good day’s work….

Until now, the notoriously cheerless minister, Nicholas Ridley, has always been vilified as the villain of the piece, but he clearly had a most ardent advocate on this occasion. Back in 1986, the newly-launched Wealden Line Campaign tried its utmost to get BR to appreciate the Uckfield line as a truly valuable asset, instead of a liability. We proposed Tunbridge Wells West’s vast area and three lengthy platforms should be thoughtfully developed as the Royal Borough’s main station. Accordingly, services from London via Tonbridge could then so usefully end here - rather than terminating and jamming-up the town’s woefully restricted stop on the Hastings line and using up all its capacity - as Pettitt admits. Renamed Linden Park, or Pantiles, it would be adjacent to all the expensive apartments springing up. Instead, this tremendously valuable asset was thoughtlessly squandered on a supermarket; the rest simply wasted on ground-level car parking. They possessed neither intellect nor imagination in appreciating it as a thriving and vibrant hub, having two main lines to London, as well the Sussex Coast via Lewes and bestowing far greater rail capacity.

This whole shameful episode was nothing but wanton corporate vandalism. Yobs that smash-up trains are vilified and imprisoned, but this damage can be made good. Those who connive in destroying priceless public assets like the railway network are awarded OBEs, and knighthoods. Yet the public damage they inflict endures as we continue living with the consequences.

This region has suffered in particular and the Uckfield line’s fate since 1960 encapsulates this tragedy. If you don’t believe us, then heed the warning we have just seen from Tom Tugendhat MP to one of his constituents in which he says: “Given the Uckfield line relies on diesel units, it is clear that GTR [Govia Thameslink Railway] are struggling to make the line financially viable, especially given the Government control over the company now. GTR confirmed they lose money across the day and I have asked them to share information with me so we can use this as part of the case for electrification.” After having cut off the Uckfield line’s prime markets of Tunbridge Wells and the Sussex Coast, it’s comparable to amputating someone’s legs then expressing surprise they can’t walk.

As for those class 423 VEP units once-scheduled to specifically operate the electrified Uckfield and Tunbridge Wells West lines in the 1970s, one was saved for preservation. It was named Gordon Pettitt OBE.