
1: Electrification announced in 1958, to be completed by 1964, but destroyed in 1969 for ESCC’s Lewes road scheme.
2: Cllr Major James Pickering who berated closure “The most retrograde step this century” - and forced ESCC into giving an agreement to fund an A22 bridge over a reopened railway.
3: Cllr Michael Lunn alongside prospective Lewes MP Maria Caulfield and Transport Secretary Claire Perry in 2015.
A hugely significant move by the recently-elected administration for East Sussex County Council has established FULL TRACKBED PROTECTION for the notorious ‘missing link’ in the South East’s rail network. Despite opposition from Green and Liberal Democrat councillors, a robust and unequivocal motion tabled by Conservative Cllr Michael Lunn was won - thanks entirely to support from Reform and Conservative councillors.
Cllr Lunn has been an ardent and faithful supporter of the Wealden Line Campaign and BML2 for many years. In January 2015 he was personally instrumental in arranging for the Transport Minister, the Rt Hon Claire Perry MP, to visit Lewes for a presentation on the wide-scale benefits of BML2 in restoring the appallingly-treated Uckfield ‘branch’ to its rightful main line status.
Recently, in the spring of 2024, Michael immediately recognised the clandestine threat which emerged when Lewes and Wealden District Councils proposed building a so-called ‘Greenway’ predominantly upon the railway’s trackbed. Their £30k scoping study set out to ‘- assess whether it would be possible to accommodate both the Greenway and a single-track railway to ensure the reopening of the former rail line would be possible’. Fervently pushing this ‘active travel’ scheme are Green Cllr Emily O’Brien and Lib Dem Cllr Kelvin Williams, who are deceiving people by claiming it won’t hinder reopening the railway.
At last week’s County Hall meeting, Michael Lunn told councillors: “The line may have closed in 1969 - but the case for protecting its future has not disappeared”. He warned: “this infrastructure link is now at risk” and urged they consider people of all generations and the railway’s future, because the many benefits of reopening are obvious. It’s not just about direct rail links to Lewes, Brighton and the Sussex Coast, but also north to Tunbridge Wells. Furthermore, it was about restoring a much-needed alternative to the critically over-stressed Brighton line. That’s why he’d brought this motion forward, because “once the opportunity to reinstate the Uckfield line was lost - it would never return”. He said nobody opposes having a Greenway - but the trackbed must remain untouched.
Responding, Cllr Kelvin Williams claimed his Greenway would not interfere with any reinstatement of the railway. But what he won’t admit is that space for only a “low speed” single line would be left. This would seriously deplete the value, practicality and potential of the railway, while drastically sabotaging its strategic/business case. He even had the effrontery to say: “I fully support the reopening of the Uckfield line” but, from a Liberal Democrat, this is par for the course. So, does he ‘fully support the reopening”? - No, because he clearly won’t campaign for it. Indeed, he decried Cllr Lunn’s motion as “hot air being put forward” - emphasising that any reopening was “way off into the future”. His attack continued, claiming “the line had been built over” - which is completely untrue - before saying “Don’t forget, a lot of the line cannot be reinstated where it is because it’s either been built over by the A22, or other sections within Lewes - and probably the line will not follow the exact route anyway.”
Such ignorance is inexcusable. To begin with, the A22 Uckfield bypass will be raised over the railway. The original plans, publicly exhibited in 1978 at Uckfield’s Masonic Hall (which we viewed) showed the proposed A22 elevated over the trackbed with a bridge. However, knowing how ESCC Highways trickery worked, fears ensued about its impact on reinstating the railway. Deploying their usual ‘bait & switch’ trick, Highways then admitted their road would sever the trackbed ‘at grade’. Thus, thanks to Cllr Major Pickering, they were forced into the following commitment. This was ‘Resolved’ on 12th December 1978 which reads:‘ The Highways Committee agree to pay the cost of a new bridge and other works over the Uckfield Bypass should the Lewes/Uckfield Railway Line ever be re-opened.’ Therefore, in legal terms, this is not an obligatory cost for the railway’s business case.
So has it been built over elsewhere? No, as Network Rail investigated in 2008: ‘There are no physical obstructions which would preclude the rebuilding of the railway between Lewes and Uckfield, although significant infrastructure works would be required at some locations’ (this refers to the aforesaid A22 Uckfield bypass and minor roads at Isfield and Barcombe Mills). As for Cllr Williams’ assertion about “other sections within Lewes” the reinstated Uckfield line joins the London line at Hamsey, precisely as shown in Network Rail’s 2008 Engineering Study. So this dismally uninformed councillor, who imagines he is ably representing Uckfield, would do well to study the plans before thinking he’s qualified to speak on this matter.
It was extremely disturbing hearing other councillors saying the trackbed was already protected; exemplified by Ringmer’s Green Cllr Johnny Denis who shamefully declared it “inconsequential” - saying “the protections are all there." They are not. This degree of ignorance is disgraceful. Another Green councillor Georgia Taylor said she didn’t understand the motion, whilst other Lib Dems, Kathryn Field and Sarah Osborne, were equally weak; the latter reading out the ESCC ‘Officers Briefing’ which cunningly says: ‘There are no additional actions to take at this point which could strengthen the County Council’s position in respect of protecting the disused Uckfield-Lewes line from development which would prejudice its future reinstatement as such policies already exist.’ This is wholly untrue - as these officers well-know.
It is this shadowy hierarchy of scheming officials who, through their treachery, are responsible for seriously damaging the railway’s protection. After decades of steadily undermining it, they surreptitiously downgraded it in 2000 to ‘Low speed, single-track operation only’ (County Structure Plan). Across forty years now, ESCC’s Highways officers have done their utmost to prevent the line’s reinstatement. Their crowning achievement was seizing absolute control of the 2008 Lewes-Uckfield Reinstatement Study by engaging consultants to produce a failed ‘Business Case’ and even hoodwinked Network Rail into thinking they wanted the railway reinstated.
Let’s be clear, Network Rail produced a thoroughly well-investigated and extremely professional engineering study which demonstrated precisely how the line could be brought back into full operation, redoubled, electrified and with trains capable of 90mph running. They recognised its far-reaching potential, stating: ‘If this scheme was to be taken forward then it could be seen as another building block in the development of the Lewes, Uckfield, Oxted and London corridor. Later development could include shorter journey time, re-doubling any single line sections, connecting into Tunbridge Wells and electrification’. A big “YES” to all of that! But, as might be expected, ESCC officers had that purged from the ‘Final’ report.
And contrary to popular belief, reinstating Uckfield-Lewes has an extremely robust business case. The public were intentionally deceived in 2009 because ESCC wanted the trackbed for their latest piece of madness - their town centre ‘Uckfield Gyratory Road Scheme’. So how did they sabotage the business case? It was only after consultants WSP Parsons Brinkerhoff, engaged by Chancellor George Osborne in 2015 for his ‘London & South Coast Rail Study’, mentioned they’d relied on passenger figures from the ESCC 2008 study that the scam was uncovered. The County Council’s Business Case deliberately used passenger loadings from 1966 - when Uckfield’s population was 4,300 (it was14,000 even in 2008) and Crowborough’s was 9,500 (20,000 in 2008).
Further manipulation then involved discounting all the patronage from the many places the Uckfield line would inevitably serve along this expanding corridor - the Sussex coastal towns, into Kent and Surrey too. They restricted it to passenger traffic only between Uckfield and Lewes - in other words purely local traffic. The excuse we subsequently discovered was “If you add in all these extra places it all gets rather complicated” - really...? They even said the 7-mile section was “a rural area, therefore demand would be low”. Accompanied by copious amounts of crocodile tears, the County Highways officers achieved the ‘negative business case’ they wanted all along. What outstanding ambassadors they are for Sussex.
But ESCC’s crowning achievement was being witness to the travesty on 9th February 2009 in London when the Study’s Leader Cllr Rupert Simmons, (since deceased) and Highways supremo Rupert Clubb, thinking they were safe from public/media gaze, told Westminster’s All Party Parliamentary Rail Group “Society as a whole would be worse off through reopening this line”. The full Wealden Line Campaign committee only witnessed this disgraceful act of treachery after having been tipped-off about this private meeting by the then Lewes MP Norman Baker. Across 40 years now, ESCC has consistently opposed the reinstatement of the Uckfield-Lewes railway and yet these devious officers are never held to account. There should be an enquiry into the way the whole 2008 Study was manipulated and the public deceived over its result.
Furthermore, there should now be an honest and correct Business Case procured for reconstructing the railway in the manner Network Rail fully-anticipated eighteen years ago. It is painful to be reminded that their scheduled date for ‘Project Handover’ (when railway construction finished and train services would commence running) was August 2016. But this time, ESCC officers should be excluded from havingany involvement or influence. It’s akin to putting your elderly parents in “Dr Harold Shipman’s Care Home”, or enrolling your firstborn in “King Herod’s Nursery”.
And make no mistake, the Uckfield line’s very existence is under threat all the while it remains a branch. We kid you not. As the business-speak goes, it cannot ‘wash its face’. It must tap back into its profitable revenue sources of not just Lewes and South Coast towns but Tunbridge Wells too - serving these three neighbouring counties and become the truly useful, busy and profitable railway it was scheduled to be in 1962. Its redoubling, commensurate third-rail electrification (no more of this battery nonsense) alongside fast, main line operation is the only way forward. Put simply, it should at the very least, be like West Sussex’s Arun Valley Line, which is double track throughout and benefits from frequent, fast electric trains.
The immediate next step will involve the Secretary of State Heidi Alexander issuing a formal ‘Safeguarding Direction’ - a power that she has - in order to stop ESCC officers doing any further harm. And if Andy Burnham genuinely wants to see “Growth in every postcode” - then he needs to insist she does this pronto.
Cllr Lunn’s motion was successfully carried by a majority 24 votes thanks entirely to the Reform and Conservative councillors. Every one of the spineless but supposedly rail-loving, eco-conscious Greens and Lib Dems abstained from supporting the railway’s interests. Shame on them all.
In conclusion, we would like to place on record our profound thanks to Cllr Michael Lunn for his hard work by taking the initiative in putting forward his well-constructed motion and those councillors who spoke so highly in favour. Michael is a credit to not only the County of Sussex, but the whole region which the Uckfield line must now be allowed to properly serve.