The News

  BML2Logo

bringing important railway connections together

 

1) ‘Norman Baker lobbies Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin on the need to reopen Lewes to Uckfield Line’ – South Downs Observer (Lib Dem Newspaper May, 2013)

2) Latest flyer promoting Lewes Lib Dems backing to instead tarmac the trackbed for cyclists and Shanks’s Pony!

3) Cutting ribbons – will the Lib Dems grant Norman this ‘privilege’.....?


When the Wealden Line Campaign was launched four decades ago (1986), it had solid support from the Liberal Democrats and, later on, the emerging Green Party. Most of all, the Lewes MP and one-time Lib Dem Transport Minister Norman Baker built much of his political career and reputation around his unrelenting backing for reinstating the South’s infamous mainline ‘missing link’.

Upon election to Parliament in 1997 he told the House of Commons: ‘Almost as soon as it closed, a campaign was begun to secure the reopening of the line. The Wealden Line Campaign – as it is known – has consistently put the case for the reopening and has helped to keep the issue in the local papers for years. I congratulate those involved on their diligence and commitment in that respect.’

He enlightened MPs further – ‘The [East Sussex] County Council, not long after killing the line, adopted a Structure Plan Policy that is still in place today, protecting the track bed from development so as not to prejudice possible reinstatement. That has been mirrored by the Wealden District and Lewes District Local Plans.’ – Not any more, Norman!

He quite correctly explained: ‘It would make considerable sense from an integrated network point of view as it would link existing rail infrastructure at relatively little cost by means of new short stretches. That would improve the viability and profitability of the lines to which it connected, as journeys previously impossible suddenly became viable propositions.’ He then outlined the sustained community backing for reopening – ‘The line has considerable public support. I have with me a petition carrying 3,400 signatures, presented to me by George Yerby of Friends of the Earth.’

Following New Labour’s 2001 re-election he said: ‘It would be tragic if the Lewes–Uckfield line were not reopened. We must pull together and find a way of achieving that; 32 years after its closure, there is a huge campaign, which spans all councils and all parties, for the line to be reopened. The Government need to produce a route map showing how we can reopen lines that should never have been closed in the first place and where there are obvious economic, environmental and social reasons for doing so.’

During the Euro-Elections in August 2002, the Lib Dems even despatched their President, the late Charles Kennedy MP. Upon arrival at Uckfield station, he told the press that by the next European elections he hoped to ‘– do a proper whistle-stop tour and continue his journey to Lewes by train.’

Following a Lib Dem-initiated debate on transport policy in 2003, Norman Baker roundly chided the Department for Transport (DfT), saying – ‘The Government still seems fixed in the mindset that money spent on the railway is subsidy whereas money spent on the roads is investment.’ Afterwards, in reference to the Uckfield–Lewes line he told the media: ‘I have, with many others, been fighting for reinstatement for more than 15 years. The logic is unquestionable and the issue won’t go away. It is one of my ambitions in my political life to be at the reopening of the line and I intend to achieve it.’ – Well said, Norman.

After the Wealden Line Campaign revealed the actual extent of line re-openings under the Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott’s much-vaunted ‘Strategic Rail Authority’, Norman admonished: ‘Twelve miles is pathetic, given the renaissance of rail that Labour promised when it came to power some eight years ago. Many former railway lines are crying out to be reopened, not least the Lewes–Uckfield line in my constituency. The social, environmental and economic case for that is beyond question. The reopening is supported by all three parties; it would close a small gap in the network and provide an alternative to the Brighton Main Line. If we cannot reopen that line – when will any line reopen under Labour?’

Now, being a leading Lib Dem grandee and Ambassador of the Campaign for Better Transport, he was, quite rightly, highly-critical of the DfT’s obsession with road-building, as well as New Labour’s risible record on reopening rail links. Obviously those paltry few miles occurred only in Labour constituencies, so Chancellor Rachel Reeve’s recent scrapping of the Conservatives’ ‘Restoring Your Railway’ programme is no surprise.

In 2006 Norman wrote: ‘In 1969, the County Council did what even Dr Beeching had failed to do– it forced the closure of the railway line between Lewes and Uckfield. As short-sighted decisions go, this really takes the biscuit. It left the line from London through Eridge straggling like a withered leg down to a stump at Uckfield, with an absurd gap of under 8 miles to the rail junction at Lewes. That was an act of stupidity and environmental vandalism. Ever since then, there have been vigorous calls for the line to be reopened, most notably by the Wealden Line Campaign, led by the indefatigable Brian Hart. I myself have been campaigning on the issue since I was first elected to the local council in 1987.’

At pains to convince absolutely everyone of unwavering Lib Dem support for rail he went on to say: ‘I have spent many years arguing for the reopening of this line which would have significant social, economic and environmental benefits to my constituents and I will continue to do so until such time as the Government sees common sense. Reopening will be good for the economy, good for the environment and good for social mobility. It makes absolute sense. It is one of my political ambitions to be there for the reopening, indeed to help cut the ribbon. I am beginning to believe I might just make it.’

Norman was absolutely right in saying: ‘We need the reinstatement of the Lewes–Uckfield and Eridge to Tunbridge Wells lines to provide a new through route from Seaford and Newhaven to London.’ He added:‘In our towns, we need to do more to encourage the use of buses, bicycles and what my mother would call Shanks’s pony.’ – Well, that looks exactly what we’ll get if your Lib Dem chums and their Green Party cohorts have their way with their wheeling and walking proposal.....

He helpfully and correctly told Parliament: ‘The Minister will know that, ironically, the Lewes–Uckfield line survived the Beeching cuts and was closed only to facilitate a road scheme in 1969. It was closed; I want to put on record, against the wishes of British Rail.’

Echoing what the Wealden Line Campaign had been saying for many years he pressed the point, explaining: ‘There is a very good environmental case for reopening the line. It makes no sense, economically or otherwise, for the line from London Victoria to wind all the way down through Oxted to Uckfield, and stop just seven miles short of the Lewes junction. From the strategic point of view, the simplest and cheapest way to provide extra capacity between the South Coast and London would be to reopen the Lewes–Uckfield line and use that link as an alternative route.’

Upon becoming Shadow Transport Secretary in 2007, Norman set out Lib Dem policy, saying ‘I am very pleased to be able to launch this paper which makes a real commitment to long-term rail investment and identifies a number of improvements that the Lib Dems would make to the railway including the reinstatement of the Lewes–Uckfield line. The case for re-opening is overwhelming. It is clear that the line would have huge significant social, economic and environmental benefits for local people, but the Government has been blindly building scores of new roads at the expense of the development of the railway.’

He went on to promise: ‘The Liberal Democrats will transform the railways with the biggest expansion since the Victorian age. This package will have huge benefits for communities across the country, including our own area, where the Lewes–Uckfield line is set to reopen if the Lib Dems are in a position of power after the election. The reopening of the Lewes–Uckfield line is something I have campaigned for locally for over twenty years. It is vitally needed, not just to link the two towns again, but also as a key building block in providing an alternative to the heavily-congested Brighton Main Line.’

In 1969 the Uckfield line’s direct route to Brighton was irrevocably destroyed in Lewes by East Sussex County Council (ESCC). Since then the DfT has consistently dismissed all alternative schemes. During 2007–8 Network Rail produced a truly superb and detailed Engineering Study which concluded the line could be restored for around £143m and be fully-operational by 2016. However, the business case was entirely managed by ESCC which has consistently opposed any re-opening, viewing it as a direct threat to their road-building empire. Norman and the Wealden MP were used as stooges on this ESCC ‘Rail Board’ to provide gravitas, whilst ESCC achieved their desired negative BCR (Business to Cost Ratio).

Consequently, BML2 was launched to reset the whole scheme on a regional basis across London and the South East – no longer a trivial local scheme at the mercy of an ignoble local authority still intent on ensuring it will never reopen. Sadly, Norman never grasped that BML2 besides going directly to the City of Brighton and Hove, was equally going directly to Lewes, Eastbourne, Seaford, etc., and instead spent his last years in office campaigning against BML2.

The prospect of installing a 3m-wide tarmac upon the no-longer safeguarded Lewes–Uckfield trackbed appeals to the shadowy figures in ESCC and TfSE, whilst having the Greens and the LibDems thoroughly behind it is an unexpected windfall. Meanwhile, our letters to local Lib Dem and Green MPs as well as Green Party leaders remain unanswered.

Norman once complained he would not stand by and see his record ‘traduced’ by the opposition Conservatives – yet what the Lib Dems are doing now is beyond betrayal. We cannot help wondering – will they get him to cut the Greenway ribbon?

“Et tu, Brute?”