Bonkers Scheme

The distinguished Sir John Armitt CBE, FREng, FICE, chairman of the National Infrastructure Committee and former Chief Executive of Network Rail (2002–7) may regret being associated with the Sussex Greenway Project. He really should have taken a good look at the proposition before allowing his photograph and his quotes about Net Zero and ‘decarbonising transport’ to feature in its preamble.

That’s because the so-called ‘Alliance’ which currently controls both Lewes and Wealden District Councils comprising primarily Green and Lib Dem councillors are cock-a-hoop that Transport for the South East (TfSE) has kicked reinstating rail services between Tunbridge Wells and Lewes via Uckfield into the long grass. Previously a ‘mid-term’ objective (2034) – it is now beyond 2050 – if ever. We charitably gave TfSE the benefit of the doubt two years ago in welcoming their initiative – but our interpretation of them as ‘Tarmac for the South East’ has proved true.

Shall we see Sir John Armitt cycling or ‘wheeling’ on one of these ‘Strategic Active Travel Networks’ – what do you think? Neither East Sussex County Council (ESCC) nor TfSE want this Sussex mainline reopened; indeed, they have conspired to keep it defunct since it was destroyed in 1969. So what is Greenway’s role in all of this? It is claimed the ‘French Government has asked for an improved route’ for the London to Paris ‘Avenue Verte’ – which TfSE ‘has identified as a strategic priority’. This route is shown going from Newhaven to Lewes, Uckfield, Eridge, across the High Weald and up through the Surrey Hills to London. Their ‘Revised Avenue Verte’ with its smiley icon says this route will be ‘More direct, more Greenway, more heritage attractions, Sustainable tourism legacy’.

The Lib Dems are now risibly claiming the Greenway will ‘reduce road congestion’ – presumably hoping that the £30,000 of council tax-payers’ money, which Wealden and Lewes have allocated towards its ‘feasibility study’, will vindicate them. This week the Sussex Express reports Wealden is currently planning to increase Council Tax by the maximum-permissible amount, whilst its leaders have also endorsed an increase in councillors’ allowances. But they know best – as do the Greens – who became particularly angry at our website postings last year. Cllr O’Brien who signs off ‘(She/her) Green Party Councillor for Ouse Valley & Ringmer, Cabinet Member for Nature, Climate & Food Systems at Lewes District Council’ told us we were operating a ‘politically motivated misinformation campaign’ which she said was aimed at ‘discrediting their council’ – adding ‘it makes me question the seriousness of your campaign and your commitment’.

The Wealden Line Campaign has fought both tirelessly and relentlessly for forty years (since 1986) to reinstate this strategically-important railway, yet was never contacted about this Greenway proposal. Instead, we were totally ignored and presented with a fait accompli as they were determined to install a 3m-wide tarmac corridor on the trackbed. For decades we’ve had to fight to keep the former double-line trackbed safeguarded in planning policies; notably in the face of ESCC’s many attempts to have it revoked for their various road schemes. They are now claiming it is protected ‘only for a single track’ – thus seriously weakening its importance and immense potential. Initially, these Greenway advocates were intentionally vague as to whether it would go alongside – or on the railway formation. The campaign therefore decided to attend a meeting at Uckfield Civic Centre where straight answers would hopefully be given. Attending were Shane Snow, who says he’s ‘Active Travel Sponsor for Rural Design Guidance and HS2, High Speed & Major Rail Projects, Department for Transport’ and Chris Bending whose job title is ‘Director of Place’ at Wealden District Council.

Mr Snow told Uckfield Town Council ‘DfT does not consider there is a business case for a two-track railway as promoted by BML2 which is considered unaffordable’. It then transpired the Greenway would go directly on the trackbed so that people could walk the nine route miles between Lewes and Uckfield, or cycle or ‘wheel’ (presumably roller skates / skateboard / wheelchair). Wealden’s Mr Bending didn’t foresee any problem, saying that if the line was ever to reopen then the Greenway “could be lifted to one side” – his exact words....

Neither had the slightest comprehension of the railway in its regional role as depicted above, let alone why it was no longer functional. When Mr Snow, who told us he lives in Lewes, was asked if he knew why the line had been closed, he replied “Er... Beeching?” He then recommended to Uckfield Town Council that the way forward should be ‘A single track very light rail scheme Tunbridge Wells towards the South Coast’. However when questioned how this might operate by integrating with main line trains at Hamsey into Lewes station he was clueless.

Wealden Line Campaign chairman Duncan Bennett said afterwards “A typical confrontation. A complete – and not unexpected – waste of time. They have worked hard to protect their road-centric transport department over many decades. Local authorities elsewhere are far more progressive.” Duncan pointed out that quite apart from Brighton, Surrey and Kent, the population of East Sussex alone is set to increase to 628,000 by 2035. Furthermore, the ONS (Office for National Statistics) says: ‘Wealden is expected to see the greatest increase in population at 22% with an additional 43,600 people’. It also says Lewes is expected to have 11,200 more people and concludes ‘this population growth increases the need for housing, accessible transport, etc’ – which doesn’t mean buying a new pair of roller skates.

But let’s have a serious look at this Greenway proposal. Commencing in Lewes at the Phoenix Causeway, which ironically enough was entirely responsible for the line’s closure (not Dr. B) the Greenway is to use old trackbed through Malling Hill. British Rail sold this 1½ mile section for £355 to the council, after which ESCC had the river bridges demolished. By the way, this section is not required for BML2 or reinstating Uckfield–Lewes. North of Malling and near Hamsey Old Church, the Greenway is shown crossing the River Ouse. This’ll be fun because the former 3-span railway viaduct here was 236ft in length (72 metres) and was ceremoniously blown-up by ESCC in 1971. A new cycleway bridge will be required – but twice the length of the Rampion bridge (120ft / 36m) across the River Cuckmere built for the 7-mile/11km stretch of the A27 bike path costing £75m.

Assuming ESCC gets its Compulsory Purchase Orders, the Greenway will have to repurpose some thirteen underbridges to Uckfield. When asked, our DfT and HS2 expert, Mr Snow, perceived no difficulty in installing their 3m-wide Greenway through Isfield and alongside today’s 1-mile ‘Lavender Line’ run by railway enthusiasts. Will this be at a 45-degrees angle on the side of the cutting we wonder? Needless to say, the funding to construct such a surfaced route between Uckfield and Lewes would be perfectly staggering; the terrain comprising mostly embankments with cuttings preventing any route alongside the trackbed, so it would have to go on the railbed. This would suit ESCC and TfSE admirably, ensuring the railway would remain obsolete, enabling all Government transport funding to be directed towards their never-ending number of road schemes, no matter how ineffective, but keeping these authorities comfortably in business for years to come.

So if they ‘construct cycle path to one side of the track bed’ and – having got the British Horse Society involved – will train drivers be notified to ‘Please pass wide and slow’...? Providing cycle paths, so-called ‘green corridors’, places to walk, exercise and so on, is not disputed, whilst there are plenty of existing cycleways such as the Egrets Way (Lewes to Newhaven) which are in an appalling condition – these professed cash-strapped councils should be directing any such funding putting these in order. Meanwhile, this wilful intention to permanently destroy a strategic and desperately-needed railway project must be stopped.

As we have said, given his previous record, we feel Sir John Armitt should have distanced himself from this Sussex Greenway.

Now you probably thought it couldn’t get any sillier – but have we got news for you! From Uckfield northwards, it says ‘Proposed Greenway beside single track Network Rail’ – showing it running up through Buxted, Crowborough, Eridge and also into Tunbridge Wells.

Last May, Conservative Cllr Michael Lunn aptly called this whole idea “–a joke, a comedy, a Muppet show” whilst Green Cllr O’Brien said of the Wealden Line Campaign “I find it unacceptable that your group is happy to freely bandy words about like ‘stupidity’ and ‘sabotage’ in printed newsletters, emails and on your website”. Well, when it comes to clueless, these hubristic Greenway advocates – and pardon our temerity for daring to say this – would do well to open their eyes.

Quite apart from the fact that 70mph trains between London and Uckfield will pass within a few feet alongside any such ‘sustainable transport’ path were Great British Railways (as it will soon be) to even allow such a dangerous hazard, there are just a few teensy-weensy problems. Perhaps the eminent chairman of the National Infrastructure Committee, or maybe the DfT’s ‘Active Travel Sponsor for Rural Design Guidance and HS2, High Speed & Major Rail Projects’ – or possibly our illustrious and vainglorious Green and Lib Dem councillors could be so kind as to enlighten us how we shall do our ‘Active Travel’ in ‘wheeling’ or horseriding, walking and cycling, along with the kiddiewinks, over Sleeches viaduct or through Crowborough tunnel?

So let’s all go and play on the railway!